WomenWelly · Strong body. Clear head. Better information.
Beauty

The SPF Myths Dermatologists Would Like Retired

On the amount nobody applies, the difference between the two filter types, and whether you need it indoors.

Illustration for “The SPF Myths Dermatologists Would Like Retired”
Beauty · WomenWellyIllustration — WomenWelly

Sunscreen generates more misinformation than any other product in a bathroom cabinet, which is a shame, because it is the single best-evidenced intervention against skin ageing and skin cancer available over a counter.

We put the most persistent claims to two dermatologists.

“I'm wearing SPF 50, so I'm getting SPF 50”

Almost certainly not. Laboratory testing applies 2mg per square centimetre — for a face and neck, roughly a third of a teaspoon, or the two-finger-lengths rule.

Real-world application is typically a quarter to a half of that, and protection falls non-linearly. An SPF 50 applied at half thickness behaves closer to an SPF 10 than an SPF 25.

“Mineral is safer than chemical”

Both filter categories are extensively assessed and considered safe by regulators. Mineral filters — zinc oxide, titanium dioxide — sit on the surface and are excellent for reactive skin, but tend to leave a white cast and are harder to formulate elegantly.

“Modern organic filters give better broad-spectrum coverage per gram and much better wear,” says Priya Sandhu, PhD. “The best sunscreen is the one you will put on generously every day, which makes texture a safety feature.”

“SPF in my foundation counts”

Only if you apply foundation at sunscreen thickness, which essentially nobody does. Makeup with SPF is a useful supplement and a poor substitute.

The same applies to a moisturiser with SPF 15 used as a thin morning layer.

“I don't need it indoors or in winter”

UVB is largely blocked by window glass; UVA is not, and UVA drives photoageing and contributes to skin cancer risk. It is present year-round and through cloud.

If you sit by a window all day or drive regularly, daily use is reasonable. If you spend the day away from windows, the case is much weaker — dermatologists differ here, and it is a genuine grey area rather than settled science.

“Darker skin doesn't need sunscreen”

Higher melanin provides some intrinsic protection, roughly equivalent to a low single-digit SPF. It does not prevent skin cancer, and melanoma in deeper skin tones is diagnosed later and carries worse outcomes.

“It also does not prevent hyperpigmentation, which is the concern that brings most of these patients to me in the first place,” says Dr Kessler. “Sun protection is the foundation of every pigmentation treatment I prescribe.”

This article is general information reviewed for accuracy, not personal medical advice. Speak to a qualified clinician about your own health. WomenWelly is reader-supported and free to read; we buy the products we test.

Jia-Lin Tan

Beauty Director

Jia-Lin Tan leads beauty at WomenWelly. She came to journalism from cosmetic formulation, which means she reads an INCI list before she reads the front of the bottle. She covers skin barrier science, hair loss and the dermatology behind the trend cycle.

More from Jia-Lin

Read next

All Beauty

More from Beauty